Let’s be honest, baby is going to be most excited about the wrapping paper. But a first Christmas only happens once, and it’s the sweetest excuse to pick out something special!
If you’re shopping for Christmas gifts for baby’s first Christmas, this list has a mix of festive keepsakes, hands-on toys, and gifts to grow into. Some are ready for right now and others are better saved for a few months down the road, so I’ve noted which is which. These are first Christmas gifts for baby you’ll love having around.
Disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you buy something through these links, I may earn a small commission at zero cost to you.
Baby’s First Christmas Gifts 2026: 14 Sweet Ideas to Give and Keep
- Letters from the North Pole Book
One of my favorite childhood memories is when my mom would set out a beautiful copy of “The Night Before Christmas” when decorating for Christmas — but the rule was no touching the book until Christmas Eve. We had to stare at it all month long (our version of Elf on the Shelf I suppose) with the threat of Santa not bringing toys if we touched it. Then finally, on Christmas Eve right before bed, my brother, sister and I would all cuddle up to my dad while he read the coveted book to us. We’d take turns doing the pop-ups, and marvel at the pages we remembered perfectly from the previous years. Maybe you don’t make it a forbidden addition to your library like my parents did, but having a special book you read every Christmas Eve is the easiest way to make lasting memories! - mushie Sunshine Suction Spinner Toy
We have this one and love it! Great for the mirror over the changing table, bath tub, car rides, or airplane. - Silicone Press Phone Teether
Why do all babies just love a fake phone? This one is cute and I appreciate the aesthetic colors - Montessori Wooden Sensory Cards
Tactile cards are a thoughtful option for little hands. I’m always going to gravitate to the wooden options, and I haven’t seen this style sensory card before! Perfect gift for baby to explore new textures. - Audible Flash Card Learning Toy
For a child ready to explore words and sounds, this is a gift interactive game-like toy. Crew loved inserting the cards and learning new words, and it allows them to practice independent play time as well! The listing starts at age one, making it a better fit for later play than a newborn gift. - Lovevery Play Kit
Something I didn’t realize was 100% worth the money until I had my own kids: Lovevery. The quality is unmatched, and their play kits are so appropriately designed for every age. These have been the few toys that have stood the test of time between two boys, which is saying a lot! We’re still getting these kits for Crew, who is 3 years old, so the age range is wide for this one. - LCD Writing Tablet, 2-Pack
For an older sibling or a gift to save for later, drawing tablets offer a place to scribble and create. The listing specifies ages 3–5, so this isn’t one for immediate infant play, but great for littles who want an activity that doesn’t involve a screen. - 100-Piece Natural Wooden Building Block Set
A block set is such a classic option, and great for a range of ages. This is leaning more toddler-appropriate, but it’s a fun gift that will look cute in the nursery and grow with them for years. - Wooden Xylophone
For a little one ready for musical play, a wooden xylophone is a cheerful gift to explore together. When they’re small, it’s a fun gift for you to play for them, and as they grow they’ll get more curious about it! - Remote-Control-Shaped Baby Teether
For the little one fascinated by the grown-ups’ remote (aka every baby I’ve ever met), this playful shape makes a fun teether gift. - Wooden Toddler Shape-Sorting Truck
For a child ready for toddler play, a shape-sorting truck combines a vehicle theme with hands-on exploration. Consider it a gift to grow into, not a newborn toy. - Busy Board Activity Book
A busy board is a thoughtful choice for a toddler who enjoys hands-on activities. This was our saving grace on plane rides and any long car rides. Another gift that will grow with them! - Baby Balance Bike
For a child approaching their first riding adventures, a small balance bike makes a memorable gift. The listing specifies 12–24 months, so this is one to choose for the right stage rather than a newborn. Crew got this for his first birthday and still to this day (he’s almost 3.5) will jump on it and do some laps. - Sweet Cocoon Multi-Activity Baby Push Walker
For a little one nearing the right developmental stage, a push walker can be a thoughtful gift for the months ahead. I like the walkers with activities on the front of it because they can use it before they’re even standing; plus these ones tend to be a little heavier which adds needed support for when they are ready to take a few steps with it! - Wooden Musical Instrument Set
A musical set is a lovely way to plan for shared play as a child grows. The listing specifies 18 months and up, so keep this as a later-stage gift rather than an infant toy. Crew got gifted one when he was small and we played the instruments for him until he grew interest in trying them for himself. Now we break out into full blown family band practice when we’re all sitting around in the playroom. - Mon Ami Christmas Tree Truck Stuffed Animal
A Christmas-themed plush makes a sweet keepsake for a first holiday season. It’s a lovely pick for cuddles and family photos, with a little festive character to remember the occasion.
Babies grow so fast, and a gift to grow into is never a bad idea !!

Comment below if you have more baby’s first Christmas gift ideas we can keep adding to the list!
















